There is no shortage of advice on the web of the do's and don'ts for tackling SOA. One topic that I don't see discussed much is the assessment of a company's IT skills as it pertains to the ability of a company to comprehend and actually deliver on the promise of SOA. This is part one of a series that addresses the many skillsets required to deliver a Service-Oriented Architecture.
I have mentioned in the past that companies that have not invested in enterprise architecture may struggle as they shift from software development to software engineering.
Here are the wikipedia definitions of these two terms:
Software development is the translation of a user need or marketing goal into a software product
Software engineering is the application of a systematic, disciplined, quantifiable approach to the development, operation, and maintenance of software.
There is a major difference between the two. Software development is the creation of software regardless of the means used to accomplish the task. Software engineering involves using a defined set of processes, procedures, and standards with the goal of improving the reliability and maintainability of the systems being built. So for companies that don't take a software engineering approach to software development, they may have huge challenges doing SOA with their existing staff. Throughout this series I will make reference to the shift from development to engineering as a key aspect of each skills assessment as I discuss SOA evangelists, architects, developers, testers, and many others.
When kicking off an SOA initiative, companies should perform a readiness assessment to identify areas of concern and create action plans to address them. For this series of posts, I will focus on internal skills in the IT organization.
First and foremost, a SOA Evangelist is critical to the success of any SOA initiative. This person must understand SOA inside and out from the perspective of both IT and the business. From the business standpoint the evangelist must understand the business drivers, the financial impacts and ROI, and can speak to the business in their language. From the technology standpoint, the envangelist must understand all aspects of the archtiecture in order to communicate effectively to developers, testers, security professionals, architects, network and infrastructure personnel, project managers, business and process analysts, and management. The evangelist should promote SOA and importance of governance and should help establish the Center of Excellence (CoE) needed to provide oversight and enforce the principles of software engineering. I have seen and read about several instances where SOA initiatives that were successful quickly turned to chaos upon the departure of the company's evangelist. In one case, the company quickly lost sight of the business drivers and began to debate on technical issues like whether the services should be done in .Net or Java. These are the unfortunate consequences that happen when SOA is left to those who don't have a full understanding of the technical and business benefits of SOA and focus on software development as opposed to software engineering.
Characteristics of an SOA Evangelist
An SOA Evangelist should have strong leadership skills, strong technical or even architecture level skills, should be business savvy, have a grasp on core financial concepts, and be comfortable presenting to people at all levels. On the same day, the evangelist can be expected to discuss key issues with C-level executives and then roll up the sleeves and explain the advantages of the distributed nature of SOA to the technicians. This person can expect to be confronted with various pockets of resistance which is natural for initiatives that introduce new concepts to an organization. Organization change management skills are a necessity for a person in this position. One of the key challenges for a person in this position is to get the staff engaged and give them a sense of ownership. Without this, the staff may look at the the initiative as a pet project of the evangelist instead of what it is, a key initiative for the business. The evangelist will have to lean on the exectuive sponsor and top level management to help with this.
Life without a SOA Evangelist
I feel that without an SOA Evangelist, companies will struggle for a number of reasons. First, having an expert on SOA who spreads the knowledge throughout the organization is much more efficient than having various individuals coming up with their own definitions and perceptions of SOA. An evangelist can brand and market the vision of SOA for the entire company so everyone is talking the same language. Second, the evangelist also bridges the gap between the business and IT and ensures that the technologies being implemented are focused on the business needs and not the needs of IT first. In addition, the evangelist can translate IT speak to business speak and spare the business of technical details that tend to dominate conversations when technicians discuss SOA. But most importantly, there is usually many different silos within both the business and IT that must be brought together to work as one. The evangelist is likely the person who knows enough about each silo (at a high level) to help bring all of these parties together. Without cohesion between the silos the SOA initiative can spiral into chaos.
In my next post I will discuss SOA and the architects.
